Best Fresh Lobster in Brooklyn – Top Seafood Restaurants Guide
January 29, 2025
Fresh Lobster at the Best Seafood Restaurants in Brooklyn
Brooklyn is home to some of the best seafood restaurants in New York City, serving up fresh lobster, oysters, and other ocean delicacies. Whether you're craving a classic lobster roll, buttery lobster tail, or a full seafood feast, this guide will take you through the top seafood spots in Brooklyn where you can enjoy high-quality, fresh seafood.
From cozy seafood shacks to upscale dining experiences, we’ll help you discover the best places for fresh lobster in Brooklyn and why they should be on your must-visit list.
Looking to enjoy seafood at home? Check out the premium seafood selection at Global Seafoods for fresh fish and shellfish delivered straight to your door.
Top Seafood Restaurants in Brooklyn for Fresh Lobster
1. Maison Premiere – A Luxurious Lobster and Oyster Bar
📍 Location: Williamsburg, Brooklyn
⭐ Best For: Elegant dining, raw bar, and premium seafood
Maison Premiere is an award-winning seafood restaurant in Brooklyn, famous for its fresh oysters, clams, and signature lobster dishes. Inspired by New Orleans and Parisian influences, the restaurant offers a high-end seafood experience with a beautifully designed vintage setting and a stunning outdoor garden.
Must-Try Lobster Dishes:
- Maine Lobster Tail – served with garlic butter and herbs
- Lobster Royale – a full lobster experience, paired with their signature cocktails
- Seafood Tower – includes oysters, clams, shrimp, and lobster for the ultimate seafood indulgence
💡 Why You Should Visit:
✔️ Michelin-recommended seafood restaurant
✔️ Premium lobster and raw bar experience
✔️ Romantic and upscale ambiance
🔗 Want to prepare restaurant-quality seafood at home? Try premium whitefish from Global Seafoods .
2. Fisherman’s Cove – Family-Owned Caribbean Seafood Spot
📍 Location: Flatbush, Brooklyn
⭐ Best For: Caribbean-style seafood, grilled lobster, casual dining
Serving the Brooklyn community for over 25 years, Fisherman’s Cove is a must-visit for seafood lovers who enjoy bold Caribbean flavors. Their grilled and steamed lobster dishes are perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection.
Must-Try Lobster Dishes:
- Jerk Lobster Tail – infused with Caribbean spices and served with rice and peas
- Lobster Curry – slow-cooked in a fragrant, spicy coconut curry sauce
- Lobster and Shrimp Platter – a generous portion of seafood with Caribbean sides
💡 Why You Should Visit:
✔️ Authentic Caribbean flavors with fresh seafood
✔️ Affordable lobster dishes compared to high-end spots
✔️ Friendly, family-run atmosphere
🔗 Looking for a fresh seafood selection for your home cooking? Explore wild-caught fish from Global Seafoods .
3. Littleneck – The Best Lobster Rolls in Brooklyn
📍 Location: Gowanus, Brooklyn
⭐ Best For: Classic lobster rolls, sustainable seafood, relaxed vibe
If you're searching for the best lobster rolls in Brooklyn, Littleneck is the place to be. This cozy seafood eatery sources its seafood from local fishermen, ensuring fresh, sustainable ingredients in every dish.
Must-Try Lobster Dishes:
- Classic New England Lobster Roll – served with buttered brioche and creamy mayo
- Spicy Lobster Roll – with a kick of sriracha and lime zest
- Lobster Mac & Cheese – creamy, cheesy perfection with chunks of lobster
💡 Why You Should Visit:
✔️ Locally sourced, sustainable seafood
✔️ Best lobster rolls in Brooklyn
✔️ Casual and friendly atmosphere
🔗 Love seafood? Check out sushi-grade tuna from Global Seafoods for home preparation.
4. The Crabby Shack – A Fun Seafood Spot for Lobster Lovers
📍 Location: Crown Heights, Brooklyn
⭐ Best For: Crab and lobster dishes, lively atmosphere, craft beer
As its name suggests, The Crabby Shack is known for its amazing crab dishes, but their lobster offerings are just as impressive. Whether you're in the mood for a classic lobster roll or a buttery lobster tail, this spot won’t disappoint.
Must-Try Lobster Dishes:
- Butter-Poached Lobster Roll – rich, decadent, and flavorful
- Lobster & Crab Combo – for those who love both crustaceans
- Garlic Butter Lobster Legs – a unique take on traditional lobster tail
💡 Why You Should Visit:
✔️ Casual and fun seafood dining experience
✔️ Great selection of craft beers and cocktails
✔️ Affordable and delicious seafood
🔗 For a unique seafood experience at home, explore sablefish from Global Seafoods .
FAQs About the Best Seafood Restaurants in Brooklyn
What is the best time to visit these seafood restaurants?
Most of these restaurants are busiest during dinner and weekend brunch hours, so making a reservation is recommended. If you prefer a quieter dining experience, visit on weekdays before 6 PM.
Do these seafood restaurants offer takeout or delivery?
Yes! Many of these restaurants offer takeout, delivery, and catering services through platforms like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub.
Are these seafood restaurants expensive?
Prices vary. Maison Premiere and Brooklyn Crab are on the higher end, while Fisherman’s Cove and The Crabby Shack offer affordable options.
Are these seafood restaurants kid-friendly?
Yes! Brooklyn Crab and Littleneck are great for families with outdoor seating and kid-friendly menu options.
Do these restaurants serve sustainable seafood?
Most of the restaurants featured prioritize sustainably sourced seafood, ensuring freshness and environmental responsibility.
Conclusion: Your Next Seafood Adventure in Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s seafood scene offers something for every seafood lover, from classic lobster rolls to gourmet lobster feasts. Whether you're in the mood for an upscale dining experience or a laid-back seafood shack, these restaurants deliver top-tier seafood and fresh lobster.
👉 Which Brooklyn seafood spot will you visit first? Let us know in the comments!
🔗 For more seafood insights and premium seafood delivery, visit Global Seafoods .